Enneagram at Work
New episodes most Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays.
This is a podcast about understanding people at work and navigating professional relationships. We spend so much of our time at work; why not make it more enjoyable by working on creating more enjoyable relationships with our teammates?
Listen in each week to gain self-awareness, relationship management, leadership development, personal growth insights, and real-life application ideas through the lens of the Enneagram inside educational episodes and interview conversations.
Learn about bringing the Enneagram to your organization or group and view the current workshop menu at: enneagrammba.com
Enneagram at Work
264. Type 1: Improving Resources, Roles, or Reach?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Type 1 is often associated with perfectionism, high standards, and a strong sense of what is right.
But not every Type 1 looks the same.
In this episode, we explore how the Type 1 pattern of Striving to Feel Perfect (or Improving) can show up differently depending on someone’s Instinctual Bias:
- Preserving / Resources: focused on systems, details, accuracy, risk, and making sure things are done correctly
- Navigating / Roles: focused on fairness, responsibilities, expectations, and how people should work together
- Transmitting / Reach: focused on raising standards, influencing others, and pushing for meaningful improvement
We also look at:
- what each Type 1 expression can lean into at work
- one growth area for each
- why Preserving Ones may sometimes resemble Types 5 or 6
- why Navigating Ones may resemble Types 2, 3, or 9
- why Transmitting Ones can sometimes look surprisingly similar to Type 8
The important reminder is that these are behavioral similarities, not typing rules.
The question is always what strategy is underneath the behavior.
Type gives us the core strategy. Instinctual Bias helps explain how that strategy gets expressed.
*****
Resource mentioned:
Learn more about the original Instinctual Bias descriptions from Awareness to Action Enneagram here.
*****
Want to bring these kinds of conversations to your team?
Enneagram MBA workshops help teams better understand how different people communicate, process information, navigate conflict, and work together.
You can explore facilitated workshops and team-development experiences, or start with the free Enneagram Workshop Planning Kit to think through the right experience for your team.
Many times when we think of our Enneagram type ones, there is a very specific picture that comes to mind. Somebody who is always perfect, always organized. Maybe they have their closet color coded, they have their files on their computer just so well organized. They're very detail-oriented and notice all the little details of whatever it is they're working on or reading. They tend to be very rule following, potentially even critical. And yes, some ones may absolutely look that way, but but others won't. And that's what we're going to talk about today, is understanding why type ones don't all look the same and how there's actually three types of type one and how that type one strategy gets expressed will be different depending on where their attention naturally goes to. So we're going to be pulling in the awareness to action instinctual bias language, where we have preserving, navigating, and transmitting instinctual biases. We've talked about this before. We're going to specifically overlay it with the type one who is known as striving to feel perfect. Sometimes in the workplace, we'll also identify this as a pattern of improving. So type one is using the strategy striving to feel perfect at work. You know, we might experience this pattern either ourselves or notice somebody improving what could be better, more correct, more effective, more aligned with the standard. And then when we overlap that improving pattern with preserving, which is a focus on resources, or navigating, which tends to be a focus on roles, or transmitting, which tends to be a focus on your reach, we get three very different type ones who can look surprisingly different. So welcome to the Enneagram at Work Podcast. I am your host, Sarah Wallace, founder and managing director here at Enneagram MBA, a team training company where we get to bring these types of insights about the Enneagram to the workplace to help teams start to build the bridge between Enneagram information and their unique team and working styles. And we're going to start off with looking at our preserving type ones. And this type one might be very procedural, very detail focused. There's going to be another type one that we're going to talk about that's maybe a little bit more focused on fairness and responsibilities and how people should behave. And we're going to look at another type that might be a little bit more bold, intense, outspoken, and might be easy to confuse with a type eight. And so, first though, let's look at our preserving type one where we overlap striving to feel perfect with the preserving instinctual bias. So we have that improving pattern with a focus on resources. And awareness to action describes this preserving one as probably the most focused on details, mistakes, routines, and perfecting the environment. They're probably the most rigid or perfectionistic expression of all three of the type ones. And so this type one tends to kind of use that improving pattern, that improving energy towards systems, procedures, quality, resources, accuracy, safety, maintenance, risk, doing things correctly and consistently. And so their internal soundtrack may sound something like if we're gonna do this, let's make sure we do it properly. So these are the type ones that are probably gonna notice the typo, the missing step, the process that is not being followed, the future problem that nobody else has noticed, the resource that's being wasted, and and maybe the thing that needs repair before it becomes a bigger issue. So this preserving domain in general emphasizes a focus on security, resources, and well-being, maintenance, process, risk avoidance traditions. And so when you overlap that with this type one who already has a tendency to focus on many of those things, you get kind of like the most, I think, textbook type one. Well, we need these people on our team. So I hope as we go through all of these that that you, if you happen to resonate with the type one, that you A understand more about which type you are and can further get that awareness and and uh growth. If you're between types, I hope maybe this will offer some additional clarity or validation. And then if you happen to be working or leading other type ones, multiple type ones, I'm hoping that this gives you a one layer deeper of understanding and empathy uh for how to better work with them. Um, even you know, just outside of the type one structure. We're going, we're gonna go a little bit deeper and look at, okay, you might have a couple of type ones on your team, but they might require or be motivated or be paying attention to different things, even though they both resonate with the same Enneagram type. So at work, this preserving type one has a lot of strengths. One being their reliability and uh, you know, ability to see improvement, um, to be really structured. And so they can be really wonderful at quality assurance, process improvement, risk management, planning, creating systems, maintaining standards, and catching what many others, you know, of us might might miss. And so the preserving one can really help make good work repeatable, reliable, consistent. Okay. So and we need that, right? That might not sound exciting. That might be a hard for I'm thinking maybe our type sevens are over here listening and thinking snooze fest. Um, but if you really think about it, we need that energy to actually accomplish exciting things. We need, you know, the the quote unquote the boring stuff um to make this happen. So um if you happen to be a preserving one, make sure that you are leaning into that. I hope you appreciate that about yourself. Um, one thing that our preserving ones can work on is, you know, really understanding the difference between necessary improvement and unnecessary perfection? So we have covered our type one specifically in the workplace a couple of weeks ago. And one of the growth questions we had in there was does this actually need to be improved, or is it just not how I would have done it? Um, another reflection question might be is the extra effort changing the outcome enough to justify that time and energy that is being put into it. Okay. Uh and then sometimes this type is in when you're first starting on your Enneagram journey, uh, you might test high for a type one, but you might also have a type six in there. You might also have a type five in there, even if type one's not your top. And you and you still might be, gosh, what am I this or am I this? So if you're kind of stuck between, am I a six, am I a one, one of the points of confusion might be because both of these types have a tendency to anticipate, especially the preserving ones, have a tendency to anticipate problems, focus on risk, focus on being prepared, and question whether things are safe or whether whether they're correct. Um, one little kind of reflection question here that you could consider if you're stuck between these two and in your typing process is am I more so scanning because I need things to be right or because I need to feel secure and prepared. And that might sound the same, but it there's there's a little bit of a difference. And one of the things, um, there is a wonderful typing book by Ginger Lapid Bagda. She had her company is Enneagram and Business, and she matches up all of the types and helps you kind of compare each one if you're if you're kind of stuck between a couple. So that I highly recommend that resource. I'll put it in the show notes. Um, but one of the things in that book I remember from years ago was that she said both can worry, both can have anxiety about did I make the right decision? Was this the you know the right thing to do? But once a type one kind of realizes, yep, this is the path forward, this is what we need to do, not that they won't ever worry about it again, but they tend to think, okay, we have a plan, let's move forward. And the and the worry that anxiety lessens a little bit. Whereas with the type six, they can pick a direction, choose to move on something, and still be kind of swirling inside their inner committee. We could, well, what if is that really the right thing to do? Should we have actually done it this way? What if that doesn't actually work? What if I made the wrong decision? What if I did this? And again, both can both can do this, but a six is gonna have just a little bit more tendency to do that. And so that unfortunately, their worry or anxiety may never actually lessen. So that's one little nuance. Um, another one that sometimes, not always, but sometimes can come up is the distinction between a type five and a type one. And this might show up, especially with our preserving ones, because our type fives tend to be pretty um pretty contained in control of their emotions, very competent, also very detailed, uh, pretty independent and also pretty careful with their time and resources, which a preserving of all type has just a little bit more focus on, is is that is the time, the resources, the energy. So a reflection question here might be Is understanding and conserving energy my central strategy? Or am I gathering information so I can just make sure that the work is correct? Sometimes that might help. Um these are possible lookalikes, okay, um, the way that they might get expressed, not necessarily, you know, preserving one mistypes, you know, five or six. It's just these can look very similar. So again, this is another reason why we have to be very careful about focusing on behavior and continuing to understand and get curious about what's behind that behavior because all three of these could show up very much the same, but the reason why is going to be different. All right, so the next one I have here for us is our navigating type ones. This is when we're pairing the pattern of improving with a focus on roles. Awareness to action describes the navigating one as more concerned with interactions, the group, compromise, and how actions will be perceived. So it's not enough just to do what is right. It's also will others think this is the right thing to do. Their perfectionism here may show up in more in relationships and group integrity than in the kind of nitty-gritty environmental details. So here, this type of one might pay more attention to responsibilities, who has what, um, fairness, who should be doing what, professional expectations, what appropriate is what uh behavior is appropriate, reputation, group standards, whether everyone is contributing appropriately and fairly. And so their inner voice here might sound something like everyone needs to do their part and we need to do it this right way together. And so they may be the person at work saying, Well, this isn't really fair. We need to clarify who owns this project or this problem. That's not what we agreed we would work, that's not how we agreed we would work together, or we should make sure everyone has the same expectation. The navigating domain in general, across the board, regardless of of your top type, really has a focus on role clarity, trust and reciprocity, status, identity, group dynamics, and power and influence. So they they these people are really good at stepping into a room and saying, okay, I know, I know everybody's title. I looked at, you know, I looked at email signatures and I looked at the list, who's gonna be in here. So I know the titles, but also I'm paying attention to who really has the power, like who's really in charge, you know, paying attention to kind of those interpersonal dynamics as well is something that our navigating um types of all of all types uh really pay attention to. So at work, we need, like all of these, we need some of that navigating one energy to help us improve how the group functions. So this type of the navigating one can bring a lot of fairness and accountability, very clear roles and responsibilities are being laid out here from this person, um, strong norms, integrity, thoughtful consideration of others and consistency between what they say they value and their actual behavior. And that builds a lot of trust, that builds a lot of integrity. I think that also can build a lot of influence. This person can be very influential with all of these things. Navigating ones can really help turn their values or the values of the company, the team into expectations for how people actually work together. Now, we all have these, we all have overuse strengths, we all have things we need to work on, potential blind spots, challenges. And one of the challenges here for our navigating ones could be getting caught between I know what the right thing is, and but how will people react if I say or do it? So a reflection question here might be Am I trying to do what I believe is right? Or am I trying to be seen as the person who is doing it right? Um, another one might be, have I clearly communicated the expectation? Or am I judging someone against the standard they don't even know exists? That's a really good one. I I really like that one. Um and so something to consider could be some questions to ask your type one team member if you happen to be leading a navigating, you think you might be leading a navigating type one. Um, some of their look-alike types might be a type two. Um, a navigating white one may also be very or more so relational than the other two, um, more helpful, attentive to people, concerned about how there's how others are going to be impacted by a decision. Um, one thing to consider is am I adopting, I'm sorry, am I adapting around people mainly because I want to maintain that connection, which would be very much type two, or because I have this kind of internal standard of how relationships and responsibility should work. I'm gonna read that one again because I think that that is a very powerful reflection question. If you happen to be stuck between, am I one, am I a two? And the question again, the reflection question here is am I adapting around people primarily? Am I changing my behavior? Am I doing something different? Um, because I'm really focused on maintaining that connection, or because I have an internal standard for how relationships and responsibilities could work. Um, I think the same thing could be true for an Enneagram type three, which sometimes also is a look-alike. And this is one that that does come up quite often. Uh, am I a one or am I a three? And you know, these are both focused on expectations and managing their reputation and how they're perceived and what good performance looked like, and what is the organization value? How should I present myself appropriately in this role, in this situation? They're both probably gonna have a uh a skill to be able to adapt to the group or the workplace, whatever's normal for them. Um, and so there is a lot of similar presenting behavior, but again, it's going to be a little bit different about what is driving that behavior. For a navigating one, that internal pull is still gonna be towards rightness, integrity, responsibility, and doing what should be done. And for the type three in general, that internal pull is gonna be more towards effectiveness and accomplishment and value and being seen as successful and capable, which a type one wants, but not if they have to suppress integrity and correctness a hundred percent A plus plus work. Whereas the type three has a little bit more flexibility about, hey, I want to turn in great work too. Obviously, I want starving to feel outstanding. I want to do a great job. Um, but I kind of as a three have a little bit better of a read on like, okay, we can get by with B minus work or B plus work here so that we can keep this project moving. Whereas a one, that's a little bit harder to do because they kind of have this, you know, how you do one thing is how you do everything type of mentality. Um, and so a couple, you know, a reflection question here might be, you know, for a type a navigating one, they might be thinking, what is the right way for someone in my role to handle this? Whereas a type three might be thinking, uh, what does success require from me in this situation? Um, our type nine is another one, our our type nines are another one that sometimes can get confused with a type one. And this could happen, this look-alike behavior could happen because um for the type nine, uh, they are a little bit more diplomatic, they tend to be a little bit more considerate. Um, but they're probably going to be a little bit more compromise-oriented than the stereotypical one. But for a navigating one, that might show up. So a question here might be am I smoothing this over because peace and harmony itself matters most? Or is it because I believe cooperation is the correct slash fair way for the group to function? Uh so, you know, this is I think this is a helpful distinction because sometimes people might, as you think about that question, you might think, okay, well, I'm not confrontational enough to be a type one. And so uh, not that type ones are necessarily confrontational. Um, they can very much compromise, but they're going to, you know, be willing a little bit more to die on a heel hill for the sake of their values and integrity. Um, more so, even even when it may not be the, you know, the biggest deal, um, more so than maybe a type nine might, or just want to be quiet to be able to move on. So um those are a couple of lookalikes. And then as we move into the very last one, or transmitting ones where we have that impact. Improving pattern, and we overlay it with the focus of reach. Awareness to action describes the transmitting type one as the most intense and vocal expression of the type. There are going to be more rigid in expectations of others and more willing to push others towards duty, responsibility, and standards. And so here they might think this transmitting type one might think if this can be better, why are we accepting less? So a transmitting one may naturally focus on raising standard standards, advocating for what's right, influencing others, correcting larger problems, challenging complacency, getting people to act, and making an impact. Transmitting in general includes a focus on asserting themselves, signaling, being influential, leaving a mark on the world, or um growing their big ideas and values and getting others to believe in those as well. So very, very influential here. And then when we overlap that transmitting with the type one, they also bring many strengths into the workplace. And I think their biggest one is really turning that strong conviction into action. And so this type can be so wonderful at advocacy, change leadership, challenging low standards, creating urgency, speaking up when others won't, rallying people around principles, holding the line when something matters, transmitting ones, just don't just see what could be better. They can really create the energy to actually change it. So at work or in life, we can sometimes overuse that energy. And for a transmitting type one, um you gotta be careful of this jump from I believe this is right to therefore everyone else should see it exactly the way I do. So here a really nice reflection question could be does this actually need my correction? Or would my influence be more effective? Another one might be, am I trying to improve the outcome or win the argument about the right way to get there? I think the biggest look alike here, and you might have already heard it, is the type eight. Sometimes people will think, gosh, I'm really stuck between a one and an eight because you can hear so many of the similarities already, right? A type eight starting to feel powerful, want to avoid being vulnerable, want to protect their people, and justice is a big focus for them. So a transmitting one can also be forceful and direct and is decisive and intense and assertive and be okay with comforting people, which sometimes the eight kind of holds the monopoly on. And so they can absolutely resemble type eight behavior. And so one of the distinctions is going to be the type eight strategy, striving to feel powerful, is really about gaining power, wanting autonomy, um, producing a result, having the power to produce a result. Whereas the one strategy is still gonna be a little bit more focused on correctness and improvement and getting things right. So they both may say, like, this needs to change, but under it, the eight might be thinking more like this isn't working. I'm gonna make something happen. Whereas the one is thinking, you know, this isn't right, it needs to be corrected. Another little nuance here between a one and an eight that we will talk a lot about inside our workshops is that an eight has a tendency to be the same person in every room with every person and to speak freely, to be direct. You know, this is who I am. I am who I am. Um, it's kind of your sometimes the overuse of that can be like, it's on you how you take that. And if you don't take it well, that sounds like a you problem. Whereas a one and a three, um, but a one in this case is going to be a little bit more maybe politically correct. Maybe they are thinking what the a is saying, but when it comes out, they're it's gonna be finessed a little bit to be said correctly, to be said the right way. Um, so they're just going to pay a little bit more attention to that. And that's not to say that an eight cannot speak polished and cannot adjust their behavior. Um, there's many other things that you'll want to look at, including what do you feel like is the strategy that you use most often, per, you know, striving to feel perfect or striving to feel powerful, improving versus asserting can help. But but that might be that might give you some clues there. So as a recap, we have the same type one, but there can be three different expressions of it, depending on where their focus naturally goes when we're you when and we can understand that focus when we're using the instinctual bias. So our uh preserving type one is focused on those resources. Let's make the system better. This person is going to tend to lead, lean into precision and processes, quality, risk awareness. You want to be very careful here of over-perfecting things and correcting everything. Um, and maybe unnecessarily correcting some things, are navigating type one, very focused on the roles. They might be thinking, let's make the way we work better. Um, and so they're going to really lean in or think about how you could lean in more as a type one to fairness and accountability and clarity and group integrity, but be careful of unspoken standards and concerns that you are maybe imposing on others as being perceived as right, that A, it may not necessarily be the right way for everybody, and two, that maybe you haven't clearly communicated. And then our last type one is the transmitting type one, where they're focused on reach and they might be thinking, let's raise the standard. So if you happen to identify with this type, really lean into your conviction and your advocacy and your ability to make change and influence, but be cautious of overly forcefully thinking that you're right, overly uh, you know, pushing your beliefs onto others or assuming that your right answer is the only answer. But whatever instinctual bias you resonate the most with, at the end of the day, a type one is a type one because their go-to strategy is that striving to feel perfect, that improving pattern is the one that they tend to use the most. So hope, like I said, that maybe you you have gotten some type clarity. Um, maybe you understand yourself a little bit better. Maybe you understand a teammate a little bit better. Um, but this just gives us more deep, I guess, deeper insight and ability to further connect and and work better with our co-workers who could be all kinds of different, different threes. Ultimately, we need to get curious. This is not an opportunity now that we have this second layer to put somebody in a box and think, okay, now that I know their instinctual bias and their type, now I can really predict behavior. You you still can't. We again 27 types here, no way to actually distill humanity down into that. But we have our type here, striving to feel perfect, that gives us the strategy and then the the instinctual bias here that can give us an idea of how that strategy will be expressed. And when we understand both, we do get just a more complete, deeper. Um, I guess I don't want to say complete, a deeper picture of how a richer picture of how that person may show up at work. So as always, I will invite you to share any feedback or awareness that you have gained as you have learned about your what sometimes are called subtypes, instincts, or instinctual biases, and how that has either helped you in your typing process or along your growth journey, you can share those experiences over at EnneagramMBA.com forward slash contact. I'd love to hear from you. These are the types of insights and conversations that are prompted inside of our standalone workshops, our retreat experiences, our team development programs. And you can find initial information and how to get started learning more about all of those to see which might be the best fit for you and your team over at Enneagrammba.com. Thank you so much for being here, and I'll see you in the next one.